How Our Brains Decide Who to Trust

Ever wonder why some people just feel trustworthy? Science shows that it’s not only about gut instinct or social cues — your brain is actively building internal maps of honesty and trustworthiness.

A 2019 study by Bellucci and colleagues used brain scans (fMRI) to explore this. Here’s what they found — in plain language.


The Brain Regions Behind Trust

When we meet someone new and form an impression of their honesty, several areas of the brain are involved:

  • Posterior cingulate cortex (PCC): helps you reflect on someone’s character.
  • Dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC): evaluates decisions logically, including social choices.
  • Intraparietal sulcus (IPS): tracks patterns and information, helping you notice consistency.

These areas create a mental “representation” of whether someone is honest.


Connections Matter

The study also looked at how different brain regions communicate. They found that when the ventromedial prefrontal cortex (VMPFC) and the temporoparietal junction (TPJ) were more strongly connected while processing honesty, people were more likely to trust that person later.

  • VMPFC: weighs value and emotional relevance — it helps decide if someone is good to engage with.
  • TPJ: supports understanding other people’s intentions and perspective.

In other words, the brain is simulating the other person’s honesty and predicting whether trusting them is safe.


What This Means for You

Trust isn’t just a feeling — it’s a neuro-cognitive process.

  • Your brain is constantly building internal models of people’s honesty.
  • Those models influence how much trust you give — even before you consciously decide.
  • Paying attention to your reactions and impressions isn’t just intuition; it’s your brain summarizing past experiences to protect you.

Key takeaway: Our brains are wired to detect honesty, and these signals guide future trust. So noticing how someone makes you feel is both valid and backed by neuroscience.


Practical Tip for Relationships

  • Notice if someone consistently keeps their word and shows integrity.
  • Pay attention to your gut and body responses — your brain has already started assessing honesty.
  • Small inconsistencies over time can influence trust more than one-off mistakes.

Trust builds gradually, but your brain is always quietly taking notes — so your impressions matter.

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.