When faced with someone who denies aggressive behavior despite witnesses to their actions, it can feel incredibly challenging. This dynamic, where one person refuses to acknowledge harmful actions even in the face of multiple accounts, is complex and often has roots in psychology and defense mechanisms. Here, we’ll explore the nature of denial, strategies to handle these situations constructively, and why empathy—while sometimes difficult—is a key tool for managing these encounters.

1. Understanding Denial: Defense Mechanisms in Action

Denial is a common psychological defense mechanism, one that often kicks in to protect a person from uncomfortable truths. For some individuals, accepting that they have been aggressive or hurtful can be too overwhelming, triggering denial as a means to preserve their self-image. In situations where aggressive behavior is witnessed by others, the individual might feel shame, fear of consequences, or a deep sense of vulnerability—leading them to cling to denial even more firmly.

Denial in cases of witnessed aggression can take different forms:

• Outright Denial: The individual insists the behavior never happened.
• Minimization: They may admit to some behavior but downplay its impact or intensity.
• Projection: Instead of acknowledging their aggression, they may shift the blame onto others, accusing them of provoking or being overly sensitive.

2. The Importance of Witnesses and Their Role

Witnesses play an essential role in situations involving aggression and denial. When others can attest to an individual’s behavior, it adds a layer of objectivity and accountability that can sometimes help break through denial. However, it’s not uncommon for someone in denial to invalidate or attack the credibility of witnesses, casting doubt on their accounts. The presence of multiple witnesses can sometimes act as a mirror, making the aggressor face their behavior, though this is not guaranteed.

3. Why Confronting Denial Can Be So Difficult

Directly confronting someone who is in denial can often lead to an escalation rather than resolution. When people feel “cornered,” they may intensify their defensiveness, becoming more entrenched in denial or even turning hostile. This behavior is linked to the concept of “cognitive dissonance,” where there’s a clash between one’s actions and self-perception. Admitting aggression could force the person to reconcile two contradictory beliefs: “I am a good person” vs. “I acted aggressively.” For some, the emotional toll of this acknowledgment is too great, and denial feels like a safer refuge.

4. Strategies for Addressing Denial Constructively

There are a few key strategies for addressing denial in cases of witnessed aggression, though outcomes may vary:

• Avoid Direct Confrontation: Rather than accusing the individual, approach them with curiosity and open-ended questions. For instance, “I’ve heard some people felt hurt by the conversation the other day; do you remember it the same way?”
• Provide Gentle Feedback: Using “I” statements, such as, “I noticed there was some tension earlier, and I’d like to understand your perspective,” can create a safer space for the person to reflect without feeling directly accused.
• Encourage Self-Reflection: Sometimes, suggesting a cooling-off period for self-reflection can be useful. Encourage them to consider the impact of the behavior on others by saying something like, “I wonder if you’d be open to thinking about how others might have felt.”
• Leverage Witness Testimonies Wisely: Bringing in witnesses who can calmly describe their experiences without assigning blame or judgment can sometimes lead the individual to reconsider their stance. For example, a witness might say, “I felt upset by what happened because…” rather than “You hurt me when you…”
• Focus on Resolution, Not Blame: Focusing on next steps rather than rehashing the past can sometimes yield better results. Suggest moving forward positively, which may reduce defensiveness.

5. Empathy and Boundaries: Essential Components for Emotional Safety

While empathy can feel difficult to extend to someone in denial about their aggression, it remains one of the most effective tools for fostering understanding. This doesn’t mean excusing their behavior but rather acknowledging that denial often stems from inner pain, insecurity, or shame. Recognize that the person might be dealing with unresolved issues, which doesn’t justify the behavior but can help us understand its origin.

Boundaries are equally crucial in these situations, as empathy without limits can lead to emotional burnout. Setting firm boundaries communicates to the person in denial that their behavior has real impacts while maintaining your own emotional safety. For example, if the person denies aggressive actions, it’s fair to say, “I understand this is difficult to discuss, but the way you spoke felt aggressive to me, and I need us to communicate respectfully.”

6. When Professional Support is Needed

If someone’s denial of their aggression continues to affect relationships or creates an unhealthy environment, involving a neutral third party, like a therapist or mediator, can be valuable. Therapy provides a space where denial can be gently unpacked without judgment, often revealing underlying issues that contribute to the behavior. A trained professional can facilitate open, safe dialogue, helping the person in denial gain insight and recognize patterns that may be damaging to others.

7. A Hopeful Outlook: Change is Possible

Although denial can be incredibly frustrating to deal with, it’s worth remembering that people can and do change. Self-awareness, while sometimes painful, is achievable, and many individuals eventually come to recognize and take responsibility for their actions. Patience, boundaries, and empathy all play roles in this journey, but ultimately, the individual must be willing to look inward.

In cases of aggression and denial, resilience in those affected and a calm approach can make a difference, even if progress feels slow. With support, many people can overcome denial and move towards healthier behavior, fostering better communication, self-awareness, and improved relationships for everyone involved.

Copyright © Linda C J Turner 2023 LindaCJTurner.com  All Rights Reserved.

All content on this website, including text, images, graphics, and other material, is protected by copyright law and is the property of Linda C J Turner unless otherwise stated. Unauthorized use or reproduction of the content in any form is prohibited.