When harmful behavior comes disguised as help, it becomes especially difficult for someone in rehab to recognize what’s happening. This manipulation, often referred to as “covert control” or “emotional gaslighting”, can be incredibly damaging. The person offering “help” may appear well-intentioned, even caring, but their underlying motives can be to maintain control over the vulnerable individual. This makes it challenging for the person in recovery to understand that what’s being offered isn’t truly supportive—it’s actually harming their progress.
Why People in Rehab May Not Recognize Harmful Behavior:
- Dependency and Vulnerability: During recovery, individuals are often emotionally fragile and may feel dependent on others. If someone has been in their life for a long time (a family member, close friend, or even a caregiver), the recovering person may lean on them for support and may not want to question their motives, fearing isolation or abandonment.
- Familiarity with Dysfunction: If the person in rehab has grown up in or been surrounded by emotionally manipulative or toxic relationships, they may not have a strong sense of what healthy boundaries or interactions look like. To them, emotional blackmail, guilt-tripping, or manipulation may feel “normal” or like a twisted form of love and care, especially if they’ve experienced that in their past.
- Emotional Confusion: When control comes disguised as help, it can lead to a lot of internal confusion. The person in rehab may not understand that the constant reminders of their past or repeated interventions are not true care but manipulation. This is particularly tricky because manipulative people often mask their behavior in concern, making it difficult for the recovering person to distinguish between genuine support and covert harm.
- Self-Blame: Many people in recovery already carry a heavy burden of guilt and shame about their past. A manipulative person can use this to their advantage by subtly reinforcing those feelings, making the person in rehab believe they “deserve” this type of help or control. Over time, this can erode their ability to see the situation clearly.
How to Identify Covert Control Disguised as Help:
- Guilt as a Tool: A hallmark of manipulative behavior disguised as help is the use of guilt to maintain control. For example, a person might say, “I’m only doing this because I care about you,” while making the recovering individual feel guilty for needing help or for mistakes they’ve made in the past. True support empowers someone to grow and make independent choices, while covert control keeps them feeling indebted or ashamed.
- Conditional Support: Someone who truly cares offers unconditional support. In contrast, a person who is manipulating will offer help conditionally, often expecting obedience or compliance in return. If the recovering person doesn’t do what is expected, the “help” might be withdrawn or turned into a point of contention.
- Undermining Confidence: A manipulative person often subtly undermines the recovering individual’s confidence under the guise of “helping” them avoid further mistakes. They might repeatedly bring up past failures or weaknesses, saying things like, “You can’t trust yourself to handle this,” or “You know you’ve always messed up before.” This creates dependency on the manipulator for decision-making or emotional support, all while eroding self-trust.
- Isolation as “Protection”: Manipulative individuals might try to isolate the person in rehab from others who could offer real support by framing it as a way of “protecting” them. They might suggest that other people “don’t really understand you” or “will only hurt you,” encouraging dependence on them alone. This isolation further enhances their control.
What Can Be Done:
1. Raising Awareness:
The first and most important step is raising the recovering person’s awareness about what healthy versus manipulative help looks like. However, this needs to be done delicately because people in rehab are already fragile, and sudden realizations about a manipulative relationship could trigger distress or even relapse. Here are some gentle ways to guide them toward understanding:
- Education on Healthy Relationships: Group therapy sessions or educational workshops in rehab can focus on what healthy support looks like. Through learning about healthy emotional dynamics, the recovering individual might begin to recognize the covert control they’re experiencing.
- Introducing Boundaries: Encourage the person in rehab to set small, manageable boundaries with the person who is offering “help.” For example, they can decide not to engage in conversations about the past unless it’s with a therapist or agree to take time to think before making decisions instead of being pushed into quick choices. The reaction to these boundaries from the other party will often reveal whether their intentions are truly supportive or controlling.
- Focus on Empowerment: Professional support in rehab should focus on empowering the individual to regain control over their life and decisions. When the person begins to feel more confident in themselves, they are less likely to rely on manipulative figures. Empowerment comes through therapy, skill-building, and positive reinforcement from truly supportive people.
2. Intervention by Professionals:
Sometimes, professional intervention is needed. If the person in rehab doesn’t recognize the manipulative behavior, the therapist or counselor working with them can help identify it in a non-confrontational way. This could involve:
- Therapeutic Confrontation: In a controlled, safe therapeutic environment, the professional can gently challenge the manipulative dynamics and encourage the recovering individual to reflect on how they feel in these interactions. They might ask questions like, “How does it feel when they bring up your past over and over?” or “Do you feel more empowered after talking to them, or more anxious?”
- Involvement of Family Therapy: In some cases, family therapy can be beneficial, especially if the manipulative person is a close family member. The therapist can act as a mediator, helping both sides communicate more healthily and possibly addressing the manipulative behavior in a way that encourages positive change.
3. Building a New Support Network:
A critical aspect of recovery is surrounding oneself with people who genuinely want to see the person succeed and grow. If the person in rehab is reliant on someone who’s controlling, it’s important to begin building new, healthier support systems. This could involve:
- Support Groups: Many rehab centers offer peer support groups where individuals can share their experiences and learn from others who have faced similar challenges. This can help the recovering individual realize they aren’t alone and there are other sources of support beyond the manipulative person.
- Community Reintegration: Helping the recovering person reintegrate into community activities or groups, where they can foster new, positive relationships, can gradually reduce their dependence on toxic influences.
4. Encouraging Self-Reflection:
Recovery is also a time for deep personal reflection. Encourage the person to start journaling about their interactions and emotions. Over time, they may notice patterns where they feel drained or anxious after interactions with certain individuals. Self-awareness is a powerful tool in recognizing harmful dynamics.
Final Thoughts:
When manipulative behavior is disguised as help, it can trap a person in rehab in a cycle of emotional dependence, self-doubt, and vulnerability. They may not realize the harm being done because it’s cloaked in concern or disguised as “tough love.” The responsibility of friends, family, and professionals around them is to help them see the truth—gently but firmly.
Ultimately, the goal is for the person in rehab to regain their sense of agency and self-worth, so they can make decisions for themselves without being manipulated. Breaking free from covert control is a critical step in their journey toward healing and independence.
Copyright © Linda C J Turner 2023 LindaCJTurner.com All Rights Reserved.
All content on this website, including text, images, graphics, and other material, is protected by copyright law and is the property of Linda C J Turner unless otherwise stated. Unauthorized use or reproduction of the content in any form is prohibited.
