Court-Mandated Psychiatric Evaluations

A Lawyer can play an influential role in the process by facilitating legal steps that lead to a person’s assessment or detention under mental health laws. The power to commit someone for psychiatric care rests with medical professionals and, in some cases, law enforcement, but the lawyer can trigger or support these actions through the legal system.

Here’s how a lawyer can be involved in this process:

1. Mental Health Act 1983 (MHA)

Under the Mental Health Act 1983 (MHA), individuals in England and Wales can be detained, or “sectioned,” for psychiatric care if they are deemed to be a risk to themselves or others due to mental health issues. A lawyer could help initiate this process by working with medical professionals or social services, but they do not have the power to directly commit someone.

  • Section 2: This section allows a person to be detained for assessment and can last up to 28 days. Two doctors (one of whom must be approved under the MHA) and an Approved Mental Health Professional (AMHP) must agree that the person is suffering from a mental disorder and requires detention for assessment or treatment.
  • Section 3: This section is used for treatment and can last up to six months, with the possibility of renewal. The person must meet the criteria for being a risk to themselves or others due to a mental health disorder.

A lawyer can assist by gathering evidence and supporting family members or others to raise concerns with an AMHP, who can then initiate the process of committing the individual under the MHA.

2. Role of the Lawyer

  • Representing Concerned Parties: A lawyer can represent family members, friends, or other concerned parties who believe the person poses a danger to themselves or others. The lawyer can help file an application or referral to the local authority or medical professionals to initiate an assessment under the Mental Health Act.
  • Supporting Legal Action: If the person is already involved in criminal activity, such as violent behavior or making threats, the lawyer can help in bringing the case to court, where a judge may order a psychiatric evaluation as part of the legal process. In cases where mental health issues are clear, the court may mandate psychiatric treatment rather than incarceration.
  • Court Orders: In situations where someone poses an immediate risk, a lawyer can petition the court for a Mental Health Act application, which could lead to a forced assessment or hospitalization if deemed necessary by medical professionals.

3. Mental Capacity Act 2005

If the person lacks the mental capacity to make decisions about their health or well-being, the lawyer might be involved in invoking the Mental Capacity Act 2005. This law allows for decisions to be made in the person’s best interests if they are unable to make decisions due to a lack of mental capacity.

  • Court of Protection: A lawyer can apply to the Court of Protection on behalf of concerned parties to obtain a court order, such as a deprivation of liberty order (DoLS), which may allow the person to be detained in a hospital or care home for their own protection.
  • Lasting Power of Attorney (LPA): If the individual has granted lasting power of attorney to a family member or friend, a lawyer can help them make decisions about the person’s care, including psychiatric treatment.

4. Court-Mandated Psychiatric Evaluations

If the person is involved in criminal behavior or a legal dispute that involves mental health concerns, a lawyer can request a court-ordered psychiatric evaluation. This can happen in a number of situations:

  • Criminal Cases: If the person is charged with a crime and their mental health is in question, a lawyer may request a psychiatric evaluation as part of the legal process. This could lead to the person being detained for psychiatric care if they are found to pose a danger to others due to mental illness.
  • Civil Proceedings: In cases involving threats, harassment, or domestic disputes, a lawyer can present evidence to the court that the person’s mental health is a significant factor. This can lead to court-mandated psychiatric assessments.

5. Emergency Interventions

In urgent situations where someone poses an immediate danger to themselves or others, medical professionals or the police can intervene. A lawyer may be called upon to help concerned parties navigate these emergency interventions:

  • Section 136 (MHA): The police have the power to detain a person under Section 136 if they are in a public place and appear to be suffering from a mental disorder, making them a danger to themselves or others. The person is taken to a place of safety (e.g., a hospital) for up to 24 hours, during which a mental health assessment is conducted.
  • Mental Health Crisis Teams: A lawyer can work with local crisis teams or healthcare providers to ensure that the person receives appropriate care and is assessed for their mental health needs.

6. Legal Safeguards for the Individual

  • Right to Representation: Once someone is detained under the MHA, they have the right to legal representation. A lawyer can represent the individual, ensuring that their rights are protected during the detention and treatment process. If there is a dispute about whether detention is necessary, the lawyer can challenge the detention or appeal to the Mental Health Tribunal.
  • Appeals and Reviews: If the person or their family believes the detention is unnecessary, a lawyer can help appeal the decision or request a review of the detention. The Mental Health Tribunal reviews cases where individuals have been detained to ensure that the legal criteria have been met.

Conclusion

While a lawyer in the UK does not have the authority to unilaterally commit someone to psychiatric care, they can play a crucial role in initiating the process through the legal system. A lawyer can help concerned parties present evidence to medical professionals, law enforcement, or the courts, leading to an assessment under the Mental Health Act 1983. If the individual poses a danger to themselves or others, a combination of legal and medical procedures can result in the person being committed to psychiatric care. The lawyer’s role is to ensure that all legal processes are followed and that the rights of both the individual and the people affected by their behavior are respected.

Copyright © Linda C J Turner 2023 LindaCJTurner.com  All Rights Reserved.

All content on this website, including text, images, graphics, and other material, is protected by copyright law and is the property of Linda C J Turner unless otherwise stated. Unauthorized use or reproduction of the content in any form is prohibited. 

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.