These types of friends reflect different dynamics that can create tension and frustration in relationships. Each one comes with its own challenges, but understanding their behaviors and how to navigate them can help you maintain your boundaries and preserve your peace. Let’s break down each type:
1. The Friend Who Copies You but Undermines the Same Thing
This friend mirrors your actions or decisions, but then contradicts or undermines them, possibly as a way of asserting superiority or minimizing your influence.
a) Why They Do It:
- Insecurity and Envy: Sometimes, people copy others because they admire what they’re doing or feel insecure about their own path. However, once they’ve copied you, they might undermine it because they don’t want to admit they’re imitating you or they feel threatened by your success.
- Competition: Some friends have a competitive streak. They mimic your ideas, style, or career moves, but criticize or downplay them as a way to position themselves as better or more knowledgeable.
- Control: Undermining something you’ve done after copying it can be an attempt to regain control of the narrative. By doing so, they might feel that they’re in charge of what’s “better” or “right.”
b) How to Handle It:
- Call Them Out Gently: A simple, “It’s funny, you liked this idea enough to do it, but now you’re criticizing it. What’s up with that?” can subtly point out the contradiction.
- Stay Confident: Don’t let their undermining behavior make you question your decisions or achievements. If you’re confident in what you’re doing, their attempts to minimize you won’t stick. It’s important to separate their insecurity from your reality.
- Limit Sharing: If this friend repeatedly undermines your ideas after copying them, it might be wise to limit what you share with them. Protect your space by only sharing certain parts of your life with people who uplift and respect you.
c) Reassess the Relationship:
If the copying and undermining continues, ask yourself if this friendship is built on a solid foundation. Healthy friendships don’t revolve around competition or one-upmanship. It’s okay to distance yourself from relationships that make you feel diminished.
2. The Friend Who Thinks Qualifications Count for Everything
This type of friend might constantly talk about their credentials or imply that their opinion is more valid because of their formal education or professional achievements.
a) Why They Do It:
- Status Validation: For some people, qualifications provide a sense of worth. They may have worked hard for those achievements and feel that they need to emphasize them to maintain a sense of superiority or value in the group.
- Insecurity Masked as Superiority: Often, people who feel insecure in other areas of life overemphasize their qualifications because it’s the one domain where they feel confident. It’s a way of masking self-doubt with a façade of expertise.
- Rigid Thinking: Some people genuinely believe that formal qualifications are the ultimate marker of knowledge or success. This might come from a narrow worldview, where education is equated with intelligence or wisdom, and they have trouble seeing value in other forms of experience.
b) How to Handle It:
- Acknowledge, but Redirect: If they constantly refer to their qualifications, you can acknowledge their expertise, but gently point out the broader perspective. For example, “I respect your background in this field, but there’s more than one way to approach this problem.”
- Emphasize Other Types of Knowledge: Some wisdom comes from life experience, emotional intelligence, or creativity—qualities that aren’t reflected in degrees. Highlight this in conversations by bringing up these forms of understanding: “It’s great that you studied this, but experience in real-world situations teaches a lot too.”
- Keep the Dialogue Open: Ask them questions that focus on why they hold certain opinions, rather than letting them default to their qualifications as the reason. Encourage a discussion based on ideas rather than credentials.
c) Set Boundaries:
If this friend frequently dismisses your thoughts because you don’t have the same qualifications, it may be time to set boundaries. You might say something like, “I respect your expertise, but I don’t feel like you’re listening to my perspective in this conversation.”
3. The Friend Who Won’t Give Free Professional Advice
This friend might refuse to offer advice related to their profession unless it’s paid, even though they’re your friend.
a) Why They Do It:
- Protecting Their Time and Expertise: Professionals often get asked for advice so frequently that it can become overwhelming. For example, lawyers, doctors, or therapists might feel like they’re constantly being tapped for free consultations, and they draw firm boundaries to protect their time and mental energy.
- Valuing Their Work: Some people set strict boundaries about giving free advice because they want to maintain the value of their services. If they give advice for free, they may feel that it diminishes the perceived value of their professional skills.
- Concern About Liability: In certain professions, offering advice outside of formal contexts can open them up to legal risks or misunderstandings. They may prefer to keep things professional for their own protection.
b) How to Handle It:
- Respect Their Boundaries: If your friend is firm about not giving free professional advice, it’s important to respect that. They may have very valid reasons for keeping their personal and professional lives separate.
- Don’t Take It Personally: Their refusal to offer free advice isn’t a reflection of how much they care about you; it’s more about how they’ve chosen to navigate the demands on their expertise.
- Ask for Personal, Not Professional, Input: Instead of framing a request as seeking “advice,” ask for their personal opinion. For example, “I’m curious, what’s your personal take on this?” This shifts the dynamic and keeps things casual rather than professional.
c) Understand Their Professional Ethics:
Some fields, like law or therapy, have ethical guidelines around giving professional advice in informal settings. Understanding this may help you see why they don’t offer free advice, even to close friends.
General Strategies for Dealing with Challenging Friends:
- Communicate Clearly: If these behaviors are affecting your relationship, try to communicate your feelings clearly and calmly. Let them know how their actions come across to you without blaming them.
- Set Boundaries: Boundaries are key to maintaining healthy friendships. It’s okay to protect yourself from feeling diminished, used, or undervalued.
- Practice Empathy but Prioritize Yourself: While it’s good to understand where they might be coming from (insecurity, need for validation, etc.), don’t sacrifice your own well-being. Friendship should be a two-way street.
- Reevaluate the Friendship: If these behaviors persist and cause more harm than good, it might be worth considering whether the friendship is fulfilling and healthy for you. Not all friendships need to be maintained if they don’t bring joy, support, or positivity into your life.
In Summary:
Each of these friend dynamics—whether the friend who copies and undermines, the one who overemphasizes qualifications, or the one who won’t give free professional advice—can cause friction. Addressing the issue with clarity, setting boundaries, and reassessing the value of the friendship can help you manage these situations. Friendships are meant to be supportive and respectful, and navigating these challenges can either strengthen the relationship or help you decide if it’s worth continuing.
Copyright © Linda C J Turner 2023 LindaCJTurner.com All Rights Reserved.
All content on this website, including text, images, graphics, and other material, is protected by copyright law and is the property of Linda C J Turner unless otherwise stated. Unauthorized use or reproduction of the content in any form is prohibited.
